The Use of AI and Attorney-Client Privilege
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is used every day by people for a variety or tasks, including to provide the person legal advice. The use of AI to provide legal advice is fraught with problems. Before you ask AI to provide you with legal advice, you need to determine whether or not you are waiving confidentiality and attorney-client privilege as you may be deemed by a court to have waived it. Case law is being established about the use of AI by a client, and its impact on waiving confidentiality and the attorney-client privilege continues to evolve.
The attorney-client privilege is the most sacred of all privileges in our legal system. That privilege is what protects confidential communication between a client and their attorney made for the purpose of obtaining or providing legal advice. The privilege belongs to the client. However, the client can waive it, and waiving it can happen very quickly and without intent to do so. Once it is waived, you cannot undo the waiver or cure the waiver through subsequent actions. For example, a client can waive attorney-client privilege by allowing someone else to sit in on a meeting with their attorney, by allowing someone else, including a child, to overhear a conversation with their attorney, by forwarding an e-mail from their attorney to a third party, and by telling a third party the advice they received from their attorney. These examples are not an exhaustive list. There are several additional ways that a client waives confidentiality and attorney-client privilege. The newest way is through the use of AI for your legal issue.
When you input information into public-facing AI chatbots you may have no legal expectation of privacy as the privacy policies for the chatbots often permit data collection and third-party disclosures. For example, if you use AI for the purpose of obtaining legal advice, and you subsequently share those results with your attorney, the AI-generated materials most likely are not privileged and confidentiality may not apply. One of the problems with putting information into AI, and asking it for advice about a set of facts is that most likely the facts that you input, if seen by a court or the opposing side, are going to harm your case. AI does not have the ability to provide judgment, to determine nuances, or to apply real world experience like an attorney. For example, what facts are relevant to a matter is not straightforward in every situation. In trial, for example, there are often times disputes about what facts are relevant, and which facts are not. Therefore, AI determining what facts are relevant to your matter is problematic as AI does not have the ability to make such a determination.
It is a common myth that preparation for a meeting with your attorney requires you to provide information obtained through an AI search. The reality is that your AI search most likely means that it is not confidential or privileged. Most likely, you will have forfeited the rights you had under confidentiality (the cornerstone of privilege) and attorney-client privilege (protects confidential communications between a client and an attorney for the purpose of providing or obtaining legal advice).
Another common myth is that you can ask AI chatbots to provide you a second opinion about the opinion that you received from your attorney. Never put into AI communication, documents or information you received from your attorney. Doing so breaches attorney-client privilege, which could mean a court ruling that none of your communications with your attorney are protected by attorney-client privilege. Such a result could be devastating.
Spangler and de Stefano, PLLP advise business owners and individuals about attorney-client privilege and how to maintain it.
The material contained herein is for informational purposes only, and is not intended to create or constitute an attorney-client relationship between Spangler and de Stefano, PLLP and the reader. The information contained herein is not offered as legal advice and should not be construed as legal advice.